Detroit’s automotive industry. Trois-Rivières’ pulp and paper mills. The coal mines around Heerlen. Across generations and geographies, the decline of major industries has reshaped local economies and the communities built around them.
Today, automotive manufacturing communities across Germany face similar challenges as their industry undergoes profound transformation.
When a major industry declines, the consequences can extend far beyond factory gates. Jobs disappear not only in the industry itself but also among local suppliers and businesses. Workers and families may leave in search of opportunities elsewhere, while the loss of an industry that once defined a place can erode community identity and trust in institutions.
Deep scars
In nearly half of places (47%) hit by significant industrial restructuring pressures, employment had still not recovered a decade later. But not all of these stories end negatively. About a quarter of these places managed to thrive in the wake of these pressures, recording growth in jobs, the employment rate and productivity.
Why do some places manage to turn themselves around while others get stuck in cycles of decline? Skills, innovation, infrastructure, and connectivity matter, but they explain only part of the story. How effectively places bring together and mobilise their assets, resources and people also matters.
This is the “soft infrastructure” of place transformation: local leadership brings people together around a shared vision, relationships and trust enable collective action, and a sense of local identity and pride can give communities confidence in their future. These less tangible assets rarely appear in official statistics, but they can make the difference between a place that struggles to adapt and one that finds a new path to prosperity.
Place transformation needs leaders, but not necessarily heroes
OECD research shows that effective leaders connect with the history, people and assets of a place. They convene actors who might not otherwise collaborate to develop a shared vision.
They also deliver quick wins to build trust, while developing the institutions and relationships needed to sustain longer-term investments. This last point matters in particular because while transformation can take a decade or more, political terms, funding cycles and job titles often have much shorter shelf lives.
Stories of change often revolve around visionary individuals, such as a charismatic mayor who reinvented a city. But effective place leadership is less about individual heroes than about a coalition of local actors and institutions working together towards a common vision. This includes elected officials and local government officials, of course, but also education institutes, businesses and community groups.
For example, faced with population decline, insecurity and low public trust in the
neighbourhood surrounding its campus, Tec de Monterrey’s “distritotec” initiative sought to revitalise the area. Following the development of a Campus Master Plan in 2014, it initially focused on visible, small-scale initiatives, such as public art and community festivals.
These early successes helped lay the groundwork for larger investments in public spaces, housing and walkability, contributing to a 56% population increase and 40% growth in local businesses between 2010 and 2020.
Trust and connections have an economic and social value
Social capital is another important piece of this puzzle. The networks, relationships and trust that connect people and institutions influence how knowledge spreads, how people hear about job opportunities, how businesses collaborate and how communities respond to shocks. But social capital is not distributed evenly across or within communities.

Source: Gallup World Poll, as reported in OECD Regions and Cities at a Glance 2026
And stronger social connections do not always lead to better outcomes. What matters is not just how connected a community is, but who is connected to whom, and whether these relationships encourage new ideas or reinforce existing ways of thinking.
The different paths of two American steel cities, Youngstown and Allentown, bring this into sharp focus. Following industrial decline, tightly knit networks among established leaders in Youngstown reinforced existing interests and hindered collaboration beyond established circles.
In Allentown, by contrast, connections across businesses, institutions and communities helped mobilise new ideas and resources for economic renewal.
Can pride in place become an economic asset?
How a place is perceived internally and externally also matters. In England, 62% of people were proud to live in their local area, but this ranges from 35% in Rushmoor to 87% in Richmond Upon Thames.
In places experiencing prolonged economic decline, narratives of loss can become deeply embedded in local identity. This can undermine the confidence and collective purpose needed to imagine alternative futures. But place identity can also become a powerful resource for renewal. This does not mean manufacturing a new place story through a marketing campaign.
In Naples’ Rione Sanità neighbourhood, long associated with poverty and crime, local pride has become a driving force for renewal. La Paranza, a youth-led cooperative, has helped bring neglected cultural treasures back to life, including the district’s historic catacombs, creating jobs and training opportunities for local young people.
Beyond creating economic opportunities, the initiative helped challenge negative stereotypes and rebuild local pride and belonging, giving young people the sense that they are rebuilding a future in their neighbourhood that is worth staying for.
Investing in what makes investment work
A growing number of policies and programmes, particularly those that target neighbourhood revitalisation, recognise the importance of investing in the institutions and physical spaces that bring people together, and the relationships, trust and local capacity that enable collective action.
Maryland’s (US) ENOUGH Initiative, which takes a place-based approach to child poverty, provides dedicated funding for an initial partnership development phase, giving local organisations time to build relationships and strengthen their capacity before moving into planning and implementation.
The UK’s Pride in Place Programme and Germany’s Social Cohesion programme invest in community facilities, public spaces and local organisations, while Germany’s complementary BIWAQ programme connects residents, businesses and institutions through employment and neighbourhood improvement projects. The EU’s New European Bauhaus similarly combines investment in the built environment with community participation, cultural identity and social cohesion.
None of this means that leadership, social capital or local pride can substitute for investment in skills, infrastructure or businesses. But it does mean that these investments are unlikely to reach their full potential unless they also invest in the relationships, institutions and collective capacity to make them work.
To learn more about the OECD’s work on related topics, see Transforming Places | OECD
Anna Rubin is a Counsellor with the OECD’s Local Economic and Employment Development Programme and the Manager of the OECD Local Development Forum. Previously, she was the Counsellor to the Director of the Centre for Entrepreneurship, SMEs, Regions and Cities and an Analyst in the Inclusive Growth team in the Office of the OECD Secretary-General. She also served as the project lead for the 2019 Regional Development Policy Ministerial Meeting, in which over 40 countries endorsed a joint Declaration on “Building Better Futures for Regions, Cities and Rural Areas. Prior to the OECD, she worked at a variety of policy levels, ranging from San Francisco’s Department of Children, Youth, and their Families to UNESCO. She has a B.A. in Psychology and a Master of Public Policy from the University of California, Berkeley.

