Blurb
For every €1 invested in Ireland’s Football Cooperative, research estimates €17.60 in social value. But how do you put a value on friendship, better mental health and a sense of belonging? To mark Movember, this episode explores how a simple weekly kickabout can help men get active, build connections and feel part of their community. OECD Policy Analyst Melis Aslan and Football Cooperative founder Steven O’Connell discuss how inclusive, community-led football can improve men’s physical and mental well-being, the role of social enterprises in bringing people together, and how these wider benefits can be measured and replicated in other communities.
Host
Welcome to OECD Podcasts, where policy meets people.
Shayne MacLachlan
They say football is more than a game, but could a weekly kickabout actually make us healthier, happier, and more connected to our communities? November is Movember. Now, this is a month when we put the spotlight on men’s health and wellbeing, and I guess while growing a mustache might be one way to get people talking, today we’re looking at another, which is football.
And we’re joined by Steven O’Connell, who’s the founder of Football Cooperative, a social enterprise in Ireland that’s using the beautiful game to bring men together, build friendships, and support their physical and mental health. We’re gonna find out how it all started, why football can be such a powerful tool for bringing people together, and what this tells us about the wider value of the social economy.
So, Melis from the OECD, is joined by Steven. Both of you, welcome to OECD podcasts.
Melis Aslan
Hello, Steven. So, before we kick things off properly, we need to establish something very important, just so we know who we’re really dealing with here. Which football club do you support?
Steven O’Connell
That’s a good question. To start off, I really have to say my loyalty in football goes to the Republic of Ireland team.
They’re the team that gets my heart pulse racing. We haven’t had an awful lot of success in recent times, but nevertheless, we do support them loyally, and I guess we always remember the good times and our first World Cup in Italia ’90, which brought the nation together and really inspired a lot of people, including myself, about the power of football.
Melis Aslan
Well, fair enough, and I understand your loyalty as a fan of Fenerbahce from the Turkish League, so it’s important to be loyal in bad times, and sometimes only in bad times, unfortunately, but fingers crossed. Now that we know where your footballing loyalties lie, so to speak, let’s go back to where it all started.
Where did the idea for Football Cooperative come from? Was there a particular moment when you realized football could actually be about something much bigger than the game itself?
Steven O’Connell
Absolutely. How it all started was me personally and my family moving to Dublin in 2017 and I guess, like anything, you’re trying to find a new space in the world, a new community. And the traditional sporting arena was potentially beyond me because of my age profile, but also because of having a young family and work pressures can really kind of challenge your availability.
Where it came from then was the footpath was never a place where I got exercise, and gyms can be quite costly and difficult to get into. So for me, exercise had to kind of center back to, you know, where I always got active was in a ball team-based environment, and I guess that’s where it came from.
I saw that as a necessity for me to keep up physical activity. My motivations were to get in shape and to somewhat meet new people, and the game of recreational football was going to serve that, in my opinion.
Melis Aslan
That’s really interesting, and I think what is fascinating about Football Cooperative is that it’s not just about football itself, but also about what happens beyond the pitch.
So from your experience, how can these regular, informal, let’s say, football games contribute to men’s physical and mental health and their sense of belonging in the community?
Steven O’Connell
I think the first thing to speak to is kind of refer to the evidence that’s already there about how to engage men in their health, and that speaks to a strengths-based approach. It speaks to community settings and sports settings and trying to establish a hook that can appeal to men. And I guess, you’re not going to find too hard a hook than football for people in society today. I think, what we offer, a flexible team-based, ball-based exercise is certainly appealing and a hook.
But also what football delivers is a kind of an enjoyable form of keeping active that people can get behind sustainably, that doesn’t feel like a challenge. It’s more of a space where essentially they can go to enjoy the game and play the beautiful game together with friends.
Melis Aslan
And speaking of that, is there a particular story that comes to mind, someone who’s really benefited from being part of Football Cooperative, for example?
Steven O’Connell
There’s a lot of stories, and that has been the real motivation for me as the founder to keep the journey going and has really helped in really good and bad times in terms of the journey.
So for me, I guess one of the key things that I always like to speak to is a guy called Camel. He’s from Algeria. He was living and working in Dublin for several years, and he came to us through kind of a social media posting. And ultimately, when we got to know him, he hadn’t got active and hadn’t found his way into local traditional football league teams.
And soon after a number of weeks playing with us, he got this new lease of life. You could tell he had ability. He started getting in shape, he was a regular attendee, and after a number of weeks and months playing with us, one of the guys plugged him into a local sports team, football team in the community that he was living in, and he returned to playing association football in a league team.
He has come back to say quite powerfully that only for this introduction to pick-up play-as-you-go games would he have not found his journey into the traditional 11-a-side game again.
Melis Aslan
That is very inspiring indeed. And of course, for people to benefit from all of this, they first need to feel comfortable joining in, and I think that’s where your inclusive approach really comes into play here.
So how do you reach men who might not normally join a football club or take part in organized sports? And how do you make sure everyone feels welcome, whatever their background or abilities?
Steven O’Connell
Absolutely. Essential to any community-based sport or community-based initiative is that the values and the culture is rich for everyone to feel part of.
I guess the key, is we are a place-based approach where we have recreational football sites that are locally branded, so they’re easily found online and social media for people that are new to the community and are looking for something positive in their lifestyle behavior initiative.
We have kind of developed over the years a multi-pronged approach to recruiting participants, and a lot of that has to do with working in partnerships with local stakeholders. So today we collaborate with family resource centers, the local sports partnerships, and mental health referral services, as well as the sports clubs and other community-based initiatives in that area to refer Signpost socially prescribed men the game of football in our community.
And I guess one of the strongest things we also see on top of all of this is our participant referral pathway. Guys in our group tell their friends, their neighbors, their brothers, brother-in-laws about this game. They talk about, you know, the opportunity to get active in this flexible environment that works for them.
And I guess that has been a very strong contribution to making sure that the reach and profile of participants is reflective of the communities in which we’re based.
Melis Aslan
That is really interesting, and I think this community-led approach brings us to another very important aspect of Football Cooperative, the fact that you are a social enterprise at the same time.
So what does being a social enterprise allow you to do differently from a traditional sports club, and how does that help you achieve your social mission?
Steven O’Connell
I think, I think the first thing to kind of note on that is, like, traditional sports clubs are under enormous pressure. There’s definitely, you know, a lot of competing elements in their path.
That’s either facilities, it’s about the number of teams they have to manage, the volunteers, safeguarding, all of the different pieces that are in front of them. So, I guess where Football Cooperative fits in is we kind of, you know, work in partnership with them to take on the pick-up, play as you go aspect of their offering.
And we also work with them to make sure that an asset that they have, an astroturf pitch, is actually, you know, firstly open to everyone in the community because sometimes their teams don’t always provide for that, but also that it becomes a place where they can monetize and make a kind of reliable, sustainable income stream through.
So I guess for us, the social enterprise model works quite well. It helps us collaborate, partner with the club, but also with other stakeholders. I guess as a kind of incorporated not-for-profit organization, we have been, you know, proven to show that partnerships work. But through that we’ve been able to form academic partnerships and other multi-stakeholder partnerships that have made our delivery more reliable, richer, and sustainable.
Melis Aslan
And speaking of your social mission, one thing that’s particularly interesting is that you’ve actually put a number on the impact you’re making, and the results are pretty impressive.
So you’ve worked with the South East Technological University to measure Football Cooperative social impact with the research estimating 17 euro 60 cents in social value for every euro invested. So, what does that finding mean in practice? How do you put a value on things like, I don’t know, friendships, better mental health, or feeling part of a community? And did anything in the findings surprise you?
Steven O’Connell
Sure. There was lots of richness in that academic partnership and study. I think the key thing you speak to is real numbers on the outcomes that are experienced by across different stakeholder groups, from our participants, volunteers, the community partners, and also the significant others of the participants that were examined in that study.
I think the key point, it provides us with real evidence and a very compelling case for support to engage key stakeholders, social innovation funders, and policymakers and funders to justify that what we’re doing has a real benefit, but is also credible for investment of non-financial and financial supports.
The journey with the study was quite compelling. It took over 12 months of collecting data on and off the pitch to measure the benefits that participants, especially as a primary stakeholder, experience. I guess the key thing for us is that the physical health benefit is the one that comes out as the most prevalent in terms of the, you know, the values that were achieved through that.
But notwithstanding that, benefits were also experienced across mental wellbeing, social connection, and lifestyle behaviors. And I guess to answer your question around a kind of an interesting piece, I think the, the lifestyle behavior is definitely something we see where, where men come in at a very poor physical activity level. We can see over time, not only are they starting to play and get active to our games, but they now have a baseline of fitness to get active in other forms of exercise with their families. And I guess one of the most interesting pieces of the study for me was the engagement with the significant others of the men.
That came through focus groups and interviews, and what that really spoke to was when one of the adults in a home or in a situation gets active, it triggers others to follow suit. And what outcomes that were experienced there was improved family dynamic, improved family fitness levels, and this is all important when we look at the bigger scheme of things in terms of physical activity in society. Everyone needs to be active, and when we see parents and adults get active, it does bring young people with them.
Melis Aslan
Well, that’s definitely very interesting. It’s not the first thing that comes to mind, so I think it’s very interesting to also find that there is an implication on the family relations as well of football.
And with that kind of social impact, it’s only natural to wonder whether this approach could work in other places too, potentially. So, looking ahead, what would it take to bring the football cooperative model to other communities, whether in Ireland or elsewhere? And what role could policymakers or public institutions play in helping similar initiatives like you get off the ground?
Steven O’Connell
I think this is something we have kind of pioneered on since the SROI and social value assessment, is that how do you take something that is proven to work to scale for the benefit of populations? And I guess that’s where this whole realm of implementation science comes in. We have put an implementation science lens over Football Cooperative to establish the key enablers and barriers to scaling nationally and internationally.
And I guess that has been a great framework to kind of put over what we do because it helps appreciate what we do well, but also look at some of the items that will need investment of time and expertise to improve upon to ensure scale. For me, the key thing that policymakers and funders could do is help community-based organizations to firstly gather evidence of efficacy and impact.
This is something that’s not always, you know, possible within community-based settings because of capacity constraints. And once that kind of evidence is developed, I think it’s important that the funding and the support go to the projects and the initiatives that are demonstrating a commitment to impact measurement in the future and also an ability to leverage impact to kind of build partnerships.
I think the key thing we have done is we haven’t, you know, filed and put our SROI report onto a shelf. We’ve used it as a key to leveraging partnerships, and we’ll continue to do that. We’re very committed to, you know, diversifying our funding stream away from game fees that we ask of participants to a more kind of philanthropic corporate partnerships that really pin the social outcomes we experience and deliver as a financial instrument to Football Cooperative’s long-term sustainability
Melis Aslan
Well, that’s actually kind of why we also do this at the OECD, because it’s true we need better data for better policies for better lives.
So this is a very practical example from the field on that, and hopefully we’ll see more initiatives like Football Cooperative popping up in other communities. And finally, before we close off or maybe before we blow the final whistle, imagine someone listening to us today is thinking about starting something similar in their own community.
What’s the one piece of advice you would give them?
Steven O’Connell
I think working in partnership is the whole ethos of Football Cooperative. It’s behind our name, working in multiple stakeholder engagements. And to do that, you have to do it and practice it internally first, and I guess that’s what we have achieved in Football Cooperative.
We’re a volunteer-led social enterprise. We really are open to more people supporting delivery at a local level, giving them a voice and helping them shape and co-design our offering. So that has really supported us to, you know, build the foundations for us to scale sustainably, I think.
Melis Aslan
Well, thank you very much, Steven, for the chat, and what better way to have fun, bring people together, and make a real difference than through a social enterprise?
So thank you for sharing that with us today.
Steven O’Connell
Amazing. I’m very glad to speak to us.
Shayne MacLachan
Steven and Melis, thanks so much for talking about Football Cooperative and that story in Ireland. What really stands out is that you don’t need to be the next Messi or Ronaldo to get something valuable out of football.
In fact, sometimes you can just turn up, have a kick about, and meeting new people can make a real difference. And I guess as we mark Movember, it’s a great reminder that supporting men’s health isn’t just about getting people talking, but it’s about creating spaces where friendships can grow, communities can come together, and everyone feels like they belong.
So that’s it for today’s OECD podcast episode. Thanks everyone for listening. Check out social economy at OECD online, and we hope you’ll join us soon for another OECD podcast.
Host
To listen to other OECD podcasts, find us on iTunes, Spotify, Google Podcasts, and soundcloud.com/oecd
