If you were asked to identify Europe’s most dynamic regional economies, Manchester in the United Kingdom might not be the first place that came to mind. Perhaps it should be.
Between 2015 and 2023, Greater Manchester’s economy grew by an average of 3.1% annually, twice the UK’s 1.5%. Productivity growth has also outpaced the national average. Manchester stands out.
Manchester’s success offers a lesson in how places can change their economic fortunes, and innovations in one city-region can help shape national policy.
Britain’s new Prime Minister, Andy Burnham, spent nine years as Greater Manchester’s elected Mayor. His new government’s devolutionary commitment to Rewiring the State draws on the experience of the city-region he once led. But Burnham himself emerged from a much longer civic tradition of collaboration, ambition and devolutionary activism borne of a deep-seated recognition that the city had to change path.
A city that refused to give up
Manchester was the world’s first industrial city, but by the 1980s it had experienced decades of industrial decline, population loss and urban decay. Its prospects looked bleak.
What followed was neither a miracle nor a single grand plan. From the late 1980s, successive generations of political, business and institutional leaders set about rebuilding the city’s fortunes. They recognised that Greater Manchester’s ten municipalities shared an economic future – and increasingly acted accordingly.
They developed common strategies, forged partnerships with universities and businesses, invested in transport and regeneration, and learned how to deliver complicated projects across political and administrative boundaries. Over time, Manchester built an enduring civic partnership: leaders could take decisions together, sustain priorities and persuade others to join them.
That tradition laid the foundations for Greater Manchester’s pioneering devolution agreement in 2014. Burnham inherited it in 2017 and extended it, giving the city-region a stronger political voice and pursuing ambitious programmes in transport, housing and public services.
The results are visible in the transformed skyline, growing knowledge economy and expanding transport network. And Manchester is not standing still. Major regeneration and innovation projects, including the transformation of the Piccadilly area, the Sister innovation district and MIX Manchester, are creating new spaces for businesses, research and investment. And with that, the most important thing Manchester is building is its collective capability to shape its own future.
Devolution is not a magic wand
Across countries, the evidence that devolution itself drives growth is mixed. But studies suggest that greater local autonomy brings stronger returns where government is capable, institutions cooperate and neighbouring places are strong. That is not an argument against devolution. It is an argument for taking the business of making it work seriously.
I think of this as the hardware and software of devolution. The hardware is powers, funding, fiscal autonomy and accountable institutions. The software is leadership, economic intelligence, professional expertise, trusted partnerships and the ability to turn ambition into action.
Manchester spent decades building the software, even before it acquired much of the hardware.
Still much to learn
Manchester’s success remains uneven. Productivity gains have not translated widely enough into higher household incomes. Poor health, skills gaps, housing pressures and the difficulties facing some outer towns remain formidable. Making growth improve more people’s lives may be harder than generating it.
And Manchester is no universal blueprint. The ambition should not be to make everywhere another Manchester, but to help every place shape its own economic future. That is now the challenge for England’s new devolution programme: not simply to transfer powers, but to build the capabilities to use them.
Manchester has much to show the world, but much to learn from it too. After a period of introspection, Britain is beginning to look outwards again, recognising how much it has to learn from other countries. Devolution and local growth should be no exception.
In my independent review of growth-capable devolution in England, I have drawn extensively on the OECD’s research. Regions in other countries have gone further in developing fiscal autonomy, institutional capacity and inclusive growth. The UK could learn from their successes – and their mistakes. That requires honesty about what has not worked as well as what has, at home and overseas.
When the OECD brings its Global Forum on Local Economic Development to Manchester next October, the city will have achievements to share, problems to confront and, above all, an appetite to learn.
To learn more about the OECD’s work on related topics, see Transforming Places | OECD
